Saturday 3 December 2011

The Reality of Kidderpore


By Lindsay

So I’ve just had a major eye opener. And it was expected. Yet it was harder to see than I thought it would be. Let me explain.

Last weekend we travelled to the Sunderbans, which is the rural region located in the Ganges River Delta just south of Kolkata. The Sunderbans is comprised of a few hundred small islands, some inhabited some not. The villages in the Sunderbans lack electricity and running water, and many of the villages were completely devastated by Cyclone Aila in 2009. The Sunderbans is also home to the world famous Bengal Tiger, which we spent the weekend diligently searching for, but despite our efforts we failed to see one.

Even though we didn’t see a tiger, we did see something else amazing! Our lost stop for the weekend was at a village where Destiny Reflection sponsors a Coaching Center (like a tutoring center). It was a Sunday, so the kids specifically came to the center that day to see us. They sang us songs and performed skits for us, and then we played soccer and Duck Duck Goose, and a stand-up/sit-down game that left me realizing just how out of shape I am. Haha. Anyways, while we were playing, Dr. Ro was talking with the teacher. Here are some facts:
  • Girls in the village are married between the age of 12 and 17. Maximum (MAXIMUM!) age for a girl to get married is 17.
  • Girls between 12 and 15 are often sent to the city to make money doing “domestic work”.
  •  The mother’s of the children attend the Coaching Center are likely younger that I am.
I would like to focus on the second point. The people in the village often send their girls to Kolkata to earn money for the family doing domestic work, such as working as a maid or a cook. A small percentage of those girls may actually be cooking and cleaning and earning an honest living (though I feel like no child should have to earn an honest living at age 12), but the reality is that most of these girls have been sold. Sold. Sold for less than 1000 rupees (~$20 Cdn) into the Kolkata sex trade. But, even that is uncertain. Who can say if these girls are even in Kolkata? It’s likely that they have been sent across the country to Mumbai or over the border to Bangladesh.

So I’ve spent most of the week processing this reality, but there was still a bit of a disconnect until tonight. 

This afternoon, we treated all women from Destiny to a Bollywood movie. This was our first Bollywood movie experience in the cinema, and we had a great time! It was so different to the Canadian movie experience. The cinema looked more like the Vogue Theatre in downtown Vancouver than a movie theatre, and everyone cheered and clapped and laughed through the whole movie. People were answering their phones in the middle of the movie, and true to Bengali culture, half the theatre showed up late. The whole movie was in Hindi, so of course I didn’t understand anything. However, when I laughed at something I did get or the pure cheesiness of the movie, the girl sitting beside me kept laughing at me laughing at the movie. Oh man, hilarious!

After the movie one young lady from Destiny (who for our purposes I will call Sarah) was unsure how to bus to her home in Kidderpore from Gariahat, so Martyna and I offered to taxi with her to her house, and then take a cab back to Gariahat. When I offered to accompany Sarah I knew that Kidderpore is one of Kolkata’s red-light districts, so I had an idea of the types of things I would see going there after dark. However, I can say that seeing those things with my own eyes hit me harder than expected.

We were driving in the taxi when we turned off the main road into the neighbourhood. First we passed a number of smaller market-type shops and grocers. Perfectly normal. Then came the brothels. They were generally indistinguishable from regular homes, but in front of each one was a line-up of young women. I didn’t see any that looked as young as 12, but I would say that the large majority of the women I saw were younger than I am. And there they were with their make-up and their jewellery and their tight-fitting clothing just waiting. Waiting for some disgusting pig of a man to choose her, take her inside, and do the unimaginable. And as soon as the first is finished, out she would be again waiting in the line. Can you imagine standing in a line waiting to be repeatedly raped night after night?

This is the reality of Kidderpore.

After passing a number of brothels we turned a corner and drove a little ways and dropped Sarah off at her home. So here is Sarah, a beautiful young lady living right smack in the middle of Kidderpore. Thanks to Destiny Reflection, Sarah is not one of the young women waiting in line, and I pray that she never will be.

It was in the taxi home when the reality of the situation really hit me. Those young women standing in line, those are the young women missing from the village in the Sunderbans we visited last week. There they were - the missing young women - right in front of me. So much for domestic work...

And now I am sitting comfortably in Debjani’s beautiful home writing this blog post to the world, mostly as a way for me to process and explain to you the things I have just seen. Now my heart is breaking and I am crying and I am left wondering what can I possibly do to change the reality of Kidderpore?


Friday 2 December 2011

Lunch Time Bonding



 By Martyna 

Already three months has passed since we arrived in India. The four of us constantly talk amongst ourselves how we have become expert travelers. We no longer freak out when we have to take the train. We know how to negotiate with taxi drivers, buy veggies and fruit off the street and have finally figured out how the transit system operates (figuring the bus out was an accomplishment considering that there are no bus stops and sometimes you need to jump on the bus while it is still moving). We all think that we have come a long way from the time we arrived in Mumbai at 3am, had 14 taxi drivers surrounding us and were trying to attempt to get a ride to some girl’s house who we have never met before (Anu we all love you and can’t wait to see you again). However, we feel that the greatest strives that we have made is bonding with the girls who we work with. When we first arrived at Destiny everyone was very accommodating; however, the language barrier limited our interaction. Furthermore, Destiny started receiving more orders. This is super awesome, but it was difficult to spend time together because they work so hard. In the past two months we have made a conscious effort to eat lunch with the girls every day. It is the only time that we get away from our computers and they take a break on their sewing machines. We have learned to communicate through alternative means. We are pretty sure that most of the time the girls are laughing at us, and not with us. Over the past few weeks the girls have become completely comfortable with us. We all watch Indian Bollywood music videos on Youtube together, we show them pictures of our families, we observe their creativity, and each work day we have fruit hour. The most beneficial experience with these remarkable women has been seeing them interact with one another. Having lunch a few weeks I couldn’t stop thinking how these women are so similar to us, but stronger. These are young women, who have experienced the worst atrocity imaginable, and here they are now being economically empowered, they are the breadwinners in their families, they give to their workplace community, and they are constantly laughing. They arrive at work every morning ready to be productive, and they don’t let their pasts get them down. They are happy, and this positive attitude radiates on all of us in the office. It is as a result of these amazing amazing amazing women that we have become more appreciative of our lives, realize our opportunities and are willing to use our blessings to empower other women.

Tuesday 8 November 2011

From Amritsar to Sonagachi

By Lindsay

Hello blogosphere! 

I haven’t written a blog post of my own since September, so I thought it was about time I give you an update. Right now, life in India is great! There is so much I want to tell you I’m not sure where to start...

Since I last wrote we have seen and experienced many amazing things. Here are a few of them:

The Victoria Memorial
Durga Puja Festival

Our kitty

A Canadian style pancake breakfast with all the women from Destiny Reflection

Participating in the first ever Relief Society meeting in Kolkata


The Dakshineswar Kali Temple

Really really really good chocolate!

The overnight train

The view from our hotel in Varanasi

Rowing a boat down the Ganges River in Varanasi

Cows

Good food

The Taj Mahal

A snake charmer in Jaipur

The Golden Temple in Amritsar
The Sun Temple in Konark


The Bay of Bengal 



The village of Raghurajpur




The Jagannath Temple in Puri


And that only scratches the surface of the awesome things we have been so blessed to experience in India! 

I also had my first experience with food poisoning when we were in Jaipur. We ate at a really nice restaurant full of tourists located at the City Palace, but I still ended up almost vomiting on the platform at the train station in Jaipur. I did end up eventually getting sick, and I spent 14 hours on the train from Jaipur to Amritsar in the nasty train bathroom vomiting.  By the time we arrived in Amritsar I was feeling much better, so I decided to go to the border closing ceremony at the India/Pakistan border that evening. However, on the way there I got hungry and decided to eat a bag of chips. Let’s just say I am now regretting that decision. I ended up throwing up in a parking lot full of cars and people at the India/Pakistan border. Looking back, it’s actually quite an entertaining story, but at the time it was most unpleasant.

On Friday we went to visit Freeset, which is another organization like Destiny Reflection. It is located in Sonagachi – Kolkata’s largest red-light district – and employs 180 women who were previously sexually exploited. They specialize in making t-shirts and jute bags. It was incredible being there! They grew from an organization of 20 women to 180 women in just 10 years, and it really showed me the potential that Destiny Reflection has to grow! With approximately 9000 women working in Sonagachi, there is a lot of work still to be done!

Thursday 3 November 2011

Disasters in the Hotels


By Martyna 

In India there are places where you can stay for 50 Rs/- which is roughly 1 Canadian dollar. On our trip we decided to go a little upper class and paid between 200- 500 Rs/- each per night, which amounts to 4- 10 Canadian dollars. Overall our hotel rooms were awesome, but there were slight mishaps that when we look back at the experience we find comical, and so we would like to share these with all of you.

Varanasi – Puja Guest House
-          When Lindsay opened the bathroom door the toilet literally fell of the wall. 


Agra- Jouti Continental
-           In order to get hot water you had to turn on the water heater. The electrical system was not wired properly, so when you turned on the water heater you could not touch the shower knobs, the faucet and the marble countertop or you would get electrocuted. We all learned the hard way. Lindsay didn’t realize she was getting electrocuted and could not figure out why her hand kept falling asleep.

Jaipur – Satcar Hotel
-          Surprisingly this was the only hotel where we didn’t have any problem; however Jaipur was another story.

Amritsar – Sita Niwas
-          We had a massive ant problem in our room. The beds, couch and the dresser were invested with these little creatures. We sprayed insect replant all over our belongings. This tactic may have been bad for our health, but it did the trick. Well mostly. The next morning while taking a shower there were lots of ant going down the drain. We also had cockroaches that lived in the pipe of the sink. The pervert only came out when we were showering.

You Can’t Escape the Sick Bug

By Martyna


As many of you are aware we just recently returned from a 10 day trip around North West India. We all agree that it was a remarkable trip as we saw things that we never imagined until retirement; being broke students and all. The unfortunate aspect of our trip was that we all got quite ill. Before I left on this India adventure, my best friend Piper recommended that I bring Pepto-Bismol. Best idea ever!!! Christine was the first victim to experience digestive problems in Varanasi. We have not yet figured out what meal contributed to this discomfort. In Agra I got mild diarrhea after eat at the Taj guesthouse. I was actually quite upset considering that I played it safe and ate rice that day. I really never thought that anyone could screw up rice, but I guess it happens. The worst bug got contracted in Jaipur.  After shopping for a few hours, which entails a lot of haggling, yelling, sometimes throwing, and then eventually a compromise, we decided to seek refuge in a quite bistro outdoor restaurant. Let’s just say that it was second nicest place where we ate. All of us got really excited about the chicken burgers. We don’t usually eat meat, but we were craving western food and the place seemed legitimately sanitary. We were wrong. Lindsay started feeling ill almost right away but did not have any digestive problems quite yet.
Getting onto the platform of the train station after an hour plus rickshaw ride through unpaved roads Lindsay is on her knees ready to vomit in the garbage, rat invested tracks while our train is pulling up to the station. We quickly took her to our compartment. The unfortunate aspect of this train ride was that this was the only time that we were in 3A tier, rather than our regular 2A. This meant that we were all together but we had two potential strangers which where joining us and had reserved the bottom bunks. Oh ya, the train ride from Jaipur to Amritsar is 14 hours. We managed to communicate with the guy to switch bunks with us. Poor Lindsay was up most of the night with vomiting and diarrhea.  Around 4 am the bug finally hit me as well. To our surprise Silvia never got ill although she at the burger as well. I am attributing this to her stomach of steal and her Colombian genes.
I think after a while the people on the train figured out what was going on as Lindsay and I raced to the bathroom every 15 minutes. We both agreed that this was the worst case of digestive problems we ever had; the state of the washrooms (one western toilet, the other squatting where the waste is deposited on the tracks) did not help.  Finally arriving at our hotel room in Amritsar we passed out until 3PM. We decided that if we were feeling better than we would go see the border ceremony at the Pakistan- India border. It was a really interesting experience therefore we were happy we went. Half way through the ceremony Lindsay started feeling nauseous. On our way back to the car, in the middle of the parking lot surrounded by hundreds of people Lindsay vomits on the pavement, which is when we decided that she baptized India. She felt better afterwards, but the other family in the car did not seem keen on driving back with us.  
On our way back from the border ceremony Lindsay developed a fever, so we decided that it was time she be put on antibiotics. It helped and we all were able to enjoy the golden temple the next day. Back in Kolkata Lindsay went to the doctor. The doctor has his practice around the corner of our house; it is on our running route. Recognizing the only white people that live in the neighborhood he commented on how he uses us as an example to all his patients about getting more exercise. We tend to be a spectacle when we exercise. People come out of their houses to watch us run and some people even yell at us to figure out what we are doing.  
Overall we are all doing a-lot better now, thanks to modern medicine and the Sunday that we had to recuperate and watch a season of ER!


Tuesday 18 October 2011

The Archana School for Girls


By Martyna 

A few weeks ago Dr. Ro invited us to attend a performance at the Loretta School for Girls. It was parent’s day, so to show their appreciation the students dedicated a dance show to their loved ones. The children were brave (as for many it was their first time on stage) and very meticulous in their movements. The main message portrayed was the importance of educating girls. A play was enacted throughout the dance routines of a young girl who was forced into an arranged marriage. This couple later in life had a daughter who they enrolled in school. However, the father got into a car accident and lost his arm and was not able to provide for the family. Nonetheless, the parents recognized the value of education and kept their child in the institution.

            After this performance Dr. Ro gave us a tour around the building. In the attic was a subsequent classroom. A few years ago a remarkable woman striving for social justice, Alka, founded the Archana School for Girls in the attic of the Loretta School. This school is special from any other. The girls that attend this school are destitute. They are children between the ages of 6-16 that are living on the street, and have been abandoned by their families. Many of them have experiences the suffering of repeated torture and rapes.

            The Archana School is not simply and educational haven, but also their home. The attic is a large space covered with a tin roof. A breeze continuously circulates through the room as there are no windows to withstand the elements. The attic is arranged into two sections. One area is decorated with brightly colour desks segregated into educational levels. Students are surrounded by paintings and motivational quotes on the concrete walls, blackboards and sufficient school supplies. A barrier separates the classroom from the living quarters. Roughly 100+ students live in the attic. Each student is given a cubicle where they store all their cherished belongings. The school provides them with a safe place to sleep, a washroom to bath and nutritious meals. But most importantly these girls are receiving a gift which is unconceivable by many females, an education. These children who were destine for poverty stricken conditions finally have the opportunity to pursue their dreams. What I found most astonishing was to educate, feed, bath, foster an environment of positive social reintegration and save one girl from the vulnerable streets of Kolkata costs fifty Canadian dollars annually.

SFU is AWESOME!

By Christine

Today marks 5 weeks since we have been in Kolkata – although to me it feels like it has been much longer.


Already we have seen many new places and learned so much through experience that I am constantly processing new thoughts, opinions and ideas in my mind. I am having difficulty recording all of them in my journal.

I really appreciate living, working, studying, and traveling with 3 other friends/students in Kolkata. Our learning experiences are often brought up in our conversations, which helps me to process them better.

Before we left for India, Faye – our co-op coordinator – called all of us to her office for a last minute check-in to make sure we were ready to embark on our international internship. She asked each of us to voice any concerns or feelings we were experiencing before our departure for India. This was fantastic because Faye created an opportunity for clear communication. Since then, we often have “Faye Feeling Circles” over breakfast, lunch, dinner, or anytime in between. The four of us reflect upon the experiences and feelings we have had throughout our day. Open communication constructs a healthy, co-operative, and supportive living, working, and learning environment. THANK YOU FAYE!

I love Silvia, Lindsay and Martyna very much! The four of us are like a special family that does everything together. Any other family does not necessarily do everything together. Imagine a nuclear family -- the kids go to school, the parents go to work -- everyone has their own busy schedule. But, the four of us are a special family because we do everything together. We live, cook, eat, clean, shop, commute, work, study, attend class, exercise, dance, travel, go out, and watch “ER” together. We are together ALL the time. We have got so used to it that it is weird when one of us is not around. 

I value the fact that at least one of us often has an opposing opinion because we question each other and talk about topics further. For example, when we first came to Kolkata Martyna noticed advertisements for health clinics that did CT scans and ultrasounds. She said that these clinics must be for sex determination of unborn children so that girls could be aborted. I have learned about fetal sex selection, but I did not want to believe it. I responded to Martyna’s observation by explaining that ultrasounds are also used for reasons other than fetal sex determination.

It is a huge advantage that Dr. Rochelle Tucker (aka Dr. Ro) has offered to teach us a “Directed Readings: Gender and Health” seminar while we are in Kolkata. I look forward to her seminar every week. She has selected readings that focus on gender and health both in Canada as well as India. We are learning about how social and cultural norms construct gender roles, which influences policy, social systems, and behaviour that result in individual health outcomes. Experiences from our new environment are often brought up in class discussions which helps us better understand Indian culture. THANK YOU DR. RO!

During one of our first “Gender and Health” seminar, Martyna brought up the topic of fetal sex selection in India. Dr. Ro confirmed that Martyna was correct about the advertisements created by the “All Asia Medial Institute” that advertise ultrasounds. I admire Martyna for being informed, but it is unfortunate that she was right because it means that the abortion of females is actively advertised in the community in which we currently live.

This picture is taken about 100 m away from our flat on Dover Lane.


It's a Girl! Documentary Film - Official Trailer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISme5-9orR0&feature=player_embedded

Lindsay, Martyna, Sivia and I thank both Dr. Ro and Faye for your caring and support. Thanks to your passion and commitment to student’s learning, you have created this incredible opportunity for us to live, volunteer, study and travel in India. All four of us appreciate it so much and agree that SFU is AWESOME!

Thursday 13 October 2011

Durga Puja 2011

By Silvia

The past week was Durga Puja, and the city awoke and emerged out from the gray clouds of the monsoon season to celebrate the triumph of good over evil. Many artists, carpenters, and workers from surrounding villages came together to decorate Kolkata with colourful displays of light, exuberant ornamental places of worship (pandals), and gorgeous detailed clay statues of the goddess. Durga Puja is the ceremonial worship of the ten-armed mother goddess, and one of the most important festivals in India. 







The story tells us that during the torments on earth by the evil demon Manishna the prayers of the people were answered when Lord Shiva, Vishnu, and Brahma used their radiant energies to create a godly energy in the form of a divine lady with a thousand arms. This was Durga Devi. In each arm she carries a weapon belonging to all Gods and uses a lion as a form of transportation. Durga created a large army from her breath to fight Manishna’s army eventually defeating him and killing him with her sword. The earth was liberated from evil its peace restored.




In Durga, the Gods bestowed their powers to create a beautiful goddess with ten arms, each carrying their most lethal weapon. The tableau of Durga a features her four children – Ganesh, Lakshmi, Saraswati, and Biswakarma.




The beauty of Durga Puja is that all of Kolkata work together to transform the city into a glorious glittering dreamland. Artists and influential arquitecs compete in creating huge temporary canopies known as pandals, which house the icons. The pandals are innovative by depicting themes that address modern day concerns, everything from recycling to female rights. They are basically huge works of art and a visual spectacle for all who go 'pandal-hopping' during the festival. It’s amazing how quickly these structures are built. In our neighbourhood one of Kolkata’s most elaborate pandals (Sinhgi Park Pandal) was being built.  From the wee early morning, on our way to work, we would see at least 8-10 workers carving and painting, and by the time we arrived in the evenings the workers would have multiplied to about 20, all working together as a team putting together the huge puzzle pieces of the pandal. It took them less than two weeks!





Everyone, absolutely everyone, from old to young take part in the festivities. Even the only foreigners on Dover Lane (us!) ventured out during the nights for some ‘pandal-hopping’. Of course we stuck out like a sore thumb, but that made the experience even more enjoyable. People were soo happy to see us taking part in their celebrations, they would go out of their way to greet us, ask us where we were from, and even take pictures with us. They made it their goal to show us the best of Puja by directing us to the best pandals. One of the most memorable moments was the night we decided to get Mehndi (Henna). The puja crowds in our neighbourhood were soo entertained as we walked through them holding our recently painted hands in front of us to avoid smudging. To conclude, Durga Puja was like no other festival I have experienced, it was as Lindsay puts it “Like Disneyland, The Olympics, Christmas and an art gallery all in one”, but what I enjoyed the most was to see the different roles and collaborations between different people in celebrating human’s perseverance against the world’s evils.

By Christine

Just for fun, on a Wednesday afternoon, we took the metro to North Kolkata to discover a part of the city we have not visited yet. Without a planned route, we walked south in the diction of home. Approximately every 5 blocks we would find a pandal to vist. One such pandal blew all of us away. 

At the entrance of the pandal, there were images of women in tradition Indian dress. These women were depicted filling their expected gender roles such as, cocking and taking care of babies and children. As we walked further, there were images of modern day women as athletes, doctors and astronauts.  In the interior of the pandal was of course the statue of goddess Durga, and along the walls there were images of devalued women: a women begging on the street, a women committing suicide by hanging herself, a women outweighed by money (I interpreted it as a women being sold into the sex trade).





 





Many gods combined their energies to create the goddess Durga who fights against evil. During our Gender and Health seminar, Dr. Rochelle Tucker explained that this pandal represented the goddess Durga fighting against the social and cultural norms that devalue women in India. In other words, this community in North Kolkata collaborated to design and install a pandal that draws attention to the current issue of gender equity and women’s rights in India (and around the world).

Puja is an excellent time to disseminate information to the public, especially since the streets are full of people pandal hopping. The “Women’s Rights” pandal is a good example of how pandals have been used to draw people’s attention to current issues, or present day “evils of the world.” Outside of a few pandals in South Kolkata, people were giving out health promotional pamphlets on preventing the spread of HIV AIDS, and on health behaviour that prevents against heart diseases.

Large advertizing agencies have caught on, so Puja has become quite commercialised. New advertisements were pasted on the large billboards and the entrances to large pandals were pasted with adds for Vodaphone, Mountain Dew, Garnier, Vivel soap, Dove, and Oreos.

By Lindsay

If I could describe Durga Puja to you in one word, it would be UNBELIVEABLE! In the list of unbelievable things I have seen in my life, I think it ranks at number 3:
 1.  The Vancouver Temple open house. It was my first time seeing a temple in its entirety and    wow.
 2.       The temples of Angkor Wat located just outside of Siem Riep, Cambodia. Double wow. 
 3.       The Durga Puja festival, particularly the idol immersions. 

In the next few weeks I’ll be adding the Taj Mahal and the Golden Temple to this list, so soon I will have a top 5!

As Silvia explained above, if I could describe Durga Puja to you in 5 words it would be Disneyland + the Olympics + Christmas + an art gallery (ok I realize that’s technically 7 words for all you nitpicky folks out there...). Let me explain. 

Disneyland because of the lines. Everytime we lined up to see a pandal I felt like we were waiting in line to go on a colourful amusement park ride. The fact that there were no actual rides involved is completely beside the point.




The Olympics because of the crowds. You thought there were a lot of people during the 2010 Vancouver Olympics. Well folks, I’m here to tell you that that is nothing in comparison to the crowds at Durga Puja.


Christmas for 3 reasons. The first is that it’s traditional to buy gifts for your loved ones during Durga Puja. The second is because of how commercialized the festival is. This caught me by complete surprise. I did not expect to find religious idols surrounded by Oreo cookie and Vivel soap adds, especially in India. The third is because of the lights. There were strings and strings of lights everywhere, as well as trees decorated with lights, which immediately reminded me of Christmas...a very very hot Christmas.






An art gallery, or more like the ENTIRE city was turned into an art gallery. Durga Puja is by far the BEST display of modern art I have ever seen! For all you art lovers out there, Durga Puja is something you absolutely must see before you die. Put it on your bucket list now! Here are some photos of the best pandals that we saw:

  
This one was made entirely out of glass bottles!





  
And this one was made entirely out of foam!









And this one was made entirely out of wire! Can you tell that the camel and the people below are made out of coiled electrical wires?
 

And finally, this one was made entirely out of bamboo!
 






By Martyna 

I agree with Lindsay that Durga Puja was unbelievable. If you ever have the opportunity to be immersed into this high energy celebration where you get to interact with locals, see hundreds religious monuments and attend carnivals, I recommend that you take it. Durga Puja was one of the special events I attended in my life, but I especially appreciated and enjoyed this religious week when it was coming to an end. 

Although the pandals were creative masterpieces that raised awareness about social issues, people and children were lively during carnivals and street shows, and individuals clearly worshipped the goddess Durga and what she represented, I could not shake that the funds and effort that went into this could be used for alternative interventions. In my opinion Durga Puja has become highly commercialized which took away from the primary aim of the religious celebration. These globalized sponsors created a pandal competition amongst the local districts. Hence, neighbourhoods became aggressive in creating the most elaborate religious statue. Although I appreciated the time, precision and meticulous nature that went into creating the pandals, each time I entered one I had a little voice in my head about the other issues that plague India. Kolkata alone has a poverty rate that exceeds 52%, many children are not attending schools, the unemployment rate is skyrocketing, there is no sanitation system, the healthcare system only caters to the upper class (the public health care system is inefficient) and people are dying due to starvation. If the money and energy that was expended on Durga Puja was invested in some of these social issues many health concerns could be averted. 

I was not content when Puja came to an end because of the moral difficulties I was having, but because I had the opportunity to experience the submersions of the pendals. After six days of music, chanting, lights, crowds, ice cream, and dance performances, people transport the Durga monuments to the Houghly River where she is submerged into the blessed waters. Dr. Ro, Minal, Ayanna and the rest of us rented a private boat during sunset to get closer to the action. Men would carry Durga on their backs; they would spin three times in order to show her off one last time. She was then carried down the steps to the bottom of the river where she was thrown into the sacred waters. Eventually she would be weighed down by bricks, but for the time being these statues would float on the water surrounding our boat. The men would later dunk themselves into the holy river to become more spiritually connected. During the submersions there was no marketing, no products were sold, there were no flashy lights; rather people chanted and drummed while trucks carrying 20 plus individuals  with the goddess continued to arrive at the river. This portion of the Puja was raw, purely spiritual, the way it has occurred for centuries before we came to India.